In Deb Aronson’s essay, “The Nurture of
Nature”, Aronson writes about the stresses of everyday life in the modern world
and the magic bullet solution that relieves all stresses –nature. Aronson
begins her essay with a rhetorical question, “Can contact with nature relieve
anxiety and stress, aid healing, and increase concentration?” This wordy
question in the introduction implies her thesis or the main point of her essay,
which is that nature can relieve anxiety and stress, aid healing, and also
increase concentration. To build her claim or thesis firm and persuasive, Aronson
appeals to ethos by citing various studies of authorities. For instance,
Aronson uses the ethos of Andrea Faber Taylor, who is an environmental
psychologist and postdoctoral research associate at the University of Illinois,
to explain the two types of attentions: directed attention and involuntary attention,
which were compared in the text. Then, Aronson refers to the research of Roger
Ulrich and his colleagues at Texas A&M University to support her claim that
nature is actually “nurturing” and curing people: according to the studies of Ulrich
and his colleagues, people who are exposed more to nature are showed much
calmer response to the stress or stressful situation than those who are less
exposed to nature by what they call, inoculation effect. In keeping with the
results of the researches, Aronson asserts her point by writing that what we
need to relieve and resolve stress are not exercise or artificial stuffs, such
as yoga, aerobics, coffee, and anti-anxiety pills etc., but rather it is just a
little piece of green environment, the nature. She strengthens her points by
using the quotes of Kathleen Wolf of the College of Forest Resources at the
University of Washington: “But now we are seeing that our daily lives have
constant small stressors….Consequently, even small, incremental contacts with
nature in our daily lives are beneficial.” Finally, Aronson concludes her
argument with Andrea Faber Taylor’s study of the great effect of small green
environment shown in Robert Taylor Homes housing project. Strongly appealing to
ethos, Aronson has well established her argument with strong thesis supported
by credulous researches and studies of authorities; however, Aronson’s essay
lacks her own thoughts and lacks details about the studies and researches that
were used in her essay.
No comments:
Post a Comment